I have very fond memories from my childhood of Christmas. I remember going out at night as a family and driving around the city to check out all of the “hot” spots and neighborhoods decked out with lights. I remember going over to my neighbour’s house and helping her decorate their Christmas tree and helping her wrap her gifts with beautiful paper, ribbons and candy canes. Another favourite memory includes going to see a movie on Christmas Day.
You see, I’m Jewish. So we didn’t ACTUALLY celebrate Christmas but living in Canada, you can’t ignore it either. I learned to love and respect the holiday for those celebrating it, but we never celebrated it on our own. We heard the music at the malls and on the radio, saw the decorations and enjoyed the festive spirit and holiday spell that everyone seemed to be in, but it wasn’t our holiday to celebrate. No, we have Hanukkah! Eight crazy days (so they say), but really, it’s pretty low key. Not that I don’t love the holiday or celebrating it, but as a minority, it just never had the same zest as Christmas did.
When I married my not Jewish, non-denominational husband, John, I made it clear from the start that we wouldn’t have a Christmas tree in our house. Not that I don’t love it, but Christmas, and the ways that it’s celebrated (whether religiously or not) didn’t fit in with the way we planned on raising our kids. While we did celebrate Christmas with John’s family, it was always at their house, not ours.
Often the question of Santa would come up. I tried to avoid Santa or any mention of him whenever I could. In my mind, it was a non-issue. I always thought I would just tell my kids that everyone has different beliefs and as Jews, we just don’t believe in him. Of course, my hypothetical scenarios with my hypothetical kids didn’t pan out that way in ‘real’ life.
When Kyle was in Junior Kindergarten, just a little over 4 years of age, he brought up the S word – SANTA! We were walking home from school and he said to me “Did you know that Santa is going to come to our house and bring me presents?” He stopped me in my steps. I had to take a deep breath and quickly process what he said and what was going on. I was caught completely off guard and I was not prepared. All I could master to say was “Yes! Yes he will!” And that was that! My son made the decision for both of us. If he believed and learned about Santa on his own (from his classmates I assume), who am I to take that from him. Besides, the look and smile on his face said it all. After all, he does celebrate Christmas with one side of his family and part of that is Santa.
I was sure of my decision to keep this going when last year, I witnessed Kyle running and literally LEAPING onto a strangers lap (aka, Santa). And if you know Kyle, you would know that it’s completely out of character. Clearly, he admired Santa so much and regardless of what he thought of him or for that matter, what I thought of him, I knew I made the right decision to keep up the act. So yes, even though we’re Jewish, we still believe in Santa.
******
On a personal note, I did want to say that I actually wasn’t sure about whether or not I was going to publish this post. I know that it will be frowned upon by some people in my family, some of my friends and acquaintances and some people in my community. The last thing I would want to do is make anyone upset or disappoint anyone. However, I love my culture, my traditions and my religion. I hope that by sharing this little part of me that may not be very “Jewish” doesn’t make me any less Jewish! I also know that if this is our reality, I’m sure there are others who can relate. So even if I helped make one family or even one person feel ‘normal’, than I’m glad I hit ‘publish’ on this post!
homewithaneta says
We celebrate Catholic and Muslim customs and traditions. For me I figure the more the better. The kids are exposed to many things and can identify which ever way they want to when they grow up. Your family is mixed and it’s a byproduct of that that is so special. Can’t turn of that magic.
Diane Weis says
Love your honesty and courage!!!!! Santa is like the tooth fairy to us. Some mystical figure that encourages creativity and excitement with our kids.
NJ Nowoselski says
I love this post. If you break it down: it is just a tree, it is just a guy in a suit, it is just another day, they are gifts. It is family love being shared. Each family can have there own meaning to everything they do. It is your family after all
Maya Fitz says
Yes!!! This. Exactly. That’s how traditions start, right?
mersworld says
Congrats on writing this post. I’m sure it took a lot of courage. As a Jewish family growing up, we had stockings and actually left milk and cookies. Not necessarily because it was Christmas but maybe because that is what everyone else was doing? I will have to ask my parents on that one.
We were more into the menorah though.
The “December Dilemma” creates a challenge for interfaith couples and I think you handled it perfectly! Although Santa is seen as a Christian symbol, he is really just a character who brings joy to kids during this time of year. (kind of like the tooth fairy).
All the best!
LILLIAN BROWN says
Thanks The main thing I like about the Holidays is the Family Time
sarah alexis says
I love your honesty and your willingness to adapt and accept that things don’t always go the way we “thought” they would. And your ability to embrace it too! I admire you. Thank you for sharing. ๐
loucheryl says
I love your honesty and love your post. Whatever makes you and your family happy is great. I love your photos and your awesome gingerbread house. ๐
Julie F says
It must be very hard but I think you have handled it very well and new traditions will begin!
Smicroys says
I think of Santa as non-denominational now. While he may come on a Christian holiday, Santa is just about giving and kindness. He brings toys to children. And no child should be left out.
Lorna says
Love this. Good on you for posting it – my son might have been a slight influence on Kyle’s love of Santa ๐
Maya Fitz says
Hahah – I’m sure he wasn’t the only one ๐ Thanks for your kind words!
Sarah G says
I adore your courage, never ever ever be afraid to be bold and share. This was a fantastic read, wish I could hop into the picture of the gingerbread house and eat it allll! Looks like you all had a blast! Happy holidays ๐
Danielle Leier says
Love the spirit of this article!
Jennifer says
This is awesome! Go for it. My family is also Jewish and we got brought up in Australia with Santa, Christmas, and all of the fun, magical excitement that goes with it. Yes!!!!